Sharing my experience with Windows Phone 7 vs iPhone

by rahul 9/10/2011 5:47:07 PM

Well, please don't consider this a comparison between WP7 (Mango - HTC Mozart) and iPhone. I work for Microsoft, and it is quite possible that you will consider my views biased. Nevertheless, I just wanted to let you know that these are my personal views and I am not a marketing guy Smile.

The reason I am sharing my experience is because I have used iPhone for a long time, and it is almost 6 months [as on 10th September, 2011] since I switched over from an iPhone. I thought it would be a good exercise for me to write what I am liking about Windows Phone 7 and what I still miss [the iPhone is with wifey, and she doesn't mind sharing it with me sporadically!].

Every person has a specific type of smart phone usage… and the phone suits him [or doesn't] based on it. Here are some of the things that I am absolutely in love with when it comes to WP7… [it did take some time to get used to it]

    Live Tiles -> When I looked at WP7 interface for the first time, I was like "yuck… who would like this ever!". 6 months later, I really feel wow… I didn't think apps can update the home screen in such a way. One quick glance and the phone tells me…

  1. My next Alarm is about to ring at 5:30 PM [Alarm]
  2. I have no appointments lined up today, and I can easily [Calendar]
  3. Weather of Bangalore [WeatherDuck]
  4. Missed calls + Messages + Mails if any
  5. Facebook updates [Me tile + People Hub]
  6. Latest pictures that I took [Picture hub]
  7. My favorite pictures [Keeps rotating, since I usually long press the photos and add them to the favorites. Typically photos of my daughter and wife get this honor Smile]
  8. My news application reminds me that I may want to catch up on news. -> NewsIndia

I don't keep my home screen cluttered with a lot of applications. Hence all this information is really at a glance. With an iPhone I had to do "something extra" to get this information. It was NOT a glance.

    EMail navigation -> WP7 wins hands down for me. Absolutely in love with the Metro interface. I can easily read and view my Unread mails at one shot using the Unread pivot. You need to use it to realize how fantastic it is.

    Rights protected messages -> WP7 has no issues in reading rights protected messages after Mango update… on an iPhone it was a just not possible. Absolutely love this fact since I get a lot of protected messages.

    Application opening experience -> I still miss the application opening experience on iPhone. Now that the glancing is over, let's really do something. To open an application on an iPhone I had to do the following…

iPhone

  1. Organize them using different folders. I absolutely loved it, and still do.
  2. In case I forgot, to search I simply pressed the center button twice to get to the search screen and searched for it. Simple and Effective.

WP7

  1. There is a long list of applications, and I am not a very big fan of scrolling.
  2. Thankfully, with Mango update Microsoft came up with Jump List and that made the job a lot easier.
  3. But let's say I want to search for MineSweeper [a game] it won't come up in the search list if I try to search Sad smile. What if I go to XBOX live and try to search? No go… I have to still scroll and find it!

    Bing Maps -> It has come a long way in WP7 with Mango update. I adore the local scout. Unfortunately, I am not very satisfied with it when it comes to guidance on the road. I liked Google maps on iPhone on a lot better when it comes to real time navigation.

    Calendar -> Amazingly much more useful on WP7 and one of the reasons I am not switching back to iPhone Smile

    There are quite a few other features… but they aren't deal makers or breakers for me, but they definitely add up to the experience

    Internet Tethering / WiFi hotspot -> How much I miss it on my WP7 Sad smile. With an iPhone it was a breeze and I loved it since I didn't have to carry the Internet USB stick and pay extra every month! My phone would take care of all that. This would be the 2nd top most feature I miss the most, and this can definitely force me to switch back to an iPhone or an Android phone.

    The top on my list of what I currently miss, are the games and utilities. With iPhone I had so much of choice, and the games were quite cheap too. Even the demos were a lot bigger and worthwhile to have. Take for instance, FlightControl… a demo on iPhone let's you play the game decently. The same demo on WP7 allows only 10 flights to be landed Sad smile. Crap!!! There are countless other games and applications that I badly miss on the Windows Phone 7, especially now… since I have unhooked myself from the Facebook/Twitter bandwagon. The phone no longer entertains me as much as it used to due to the lack of games and other time pass applications.

Since I am a professional and care more for the professional features like calendar, maps, email etc. I am not switching back to an iPhone yet. On the other hand, I sincerely hope and wish that more and more applications come on WP7 and make the phone worth a purchase. These are still early days, and I am hoping for the best.

Apart from marketplace issues, internet tethering and gazillions of applications on an iPhone, there is not much I am missing… but then isn't that some of the main reasons why people buy and use smart phones?



blog comments powered by Disqus

Rahul Soni

Rahul Soni  Twitter

 LinkedIn

 Facebook

 Email me



Vivek Kumbhar

Vivek Kumbhar  Twitter

 LinkedIn

 Facebook

 Email me


Stack Exchange

profile for Vivek at Server Fault, Q&A for system administrators and IT professionals

profile for Rahul Soni at Stack Overflow, Q&A for professional and enthusiast programmers

Calendar

<<  February 2012  >>
MoTuWeThFrSaSu
303112345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728291234
567891011

View posts in large calendar

All Items
Sign in

Visit Microsoft's Site

Disclaimer

The opinions expressed herein are my own personal opinions and do not represent my employer's view in any way.
© Copyright 2012, Rahul Soni

Powered by BlogEngine.NET 1.4.5.0